MINUTES
FACULTY SENATE
UNIVERSITY OF WISCONSIN-SUPERIOR
December 9, 2003
RSC 112, 3:00 PM
PRESENT: David Carroll, David Beran (for Chad Scott), Glenn Carlson, David Carroll, Orv Clark, Tim Cummings, Matt Faerber, Randy Gabrys-Alexson, James Holter, Peter Nordgren, Thomas Notton, Cecilia Schrenker, Joel Sipress, Nick Sloboda, Gloria Toivola, Julius Erlenbach, David Prior, Mary Lee Vance, Bob Kosuth, and Brad Amys.
EXCUSED: Hal Bertilson and Martha Einerson.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES: Motion (O. Clark/R. Gabrys-Alexson) to approve the Faculty Senate minutes of November 18, 2003 passed.
REPORT OF THE CHANCELLOR: Julius Erlenbach. Discussed security concerns on campus in light of recent incidents. Will make security a priority budget request to SPBC; will request a full-time, 24/7, armed police officer (to go with security, unarmed officers). Discussed state budget, indicating that tax collection has been better than expected and that we may see a mid-course correction or budget repair bill. Discussed $5M gift for new building. Capital plans will be prioritized by BOR by 8/04; Chancellor indicated that with private funding we may be bumped to near the top of the list, which could mean planning in 2005-07 and construction in 2007-09 or even 2005-07.

REPORT OF THE PROVOST: David Prior. Discussed recent meeting with Department heads, in which commitment to advising, especially in the first year, was given special attention. Discussed scholarship. Will have a long session in January

REPORTS
Chair--Joel Sipress. deferred report until discussion of General Faculty Meeting.
Secretary--Hal Bertilson. No report.

Faculty Representative--Nick Sloboda. Faculty Representative Meeting (Teleconference) December 12, 2003; 2:00 - 4:00:

Senior Vice President Cora Marrett announced that the Madison libraries will return to the semester-long loans (a time period that had been reduced recently) for faculty within the UW–System.

She also noted that, regarding credit transfers, the technical colleges have yet to come up with a standardized gen .ed. curriculum policy among their colleges. On the matter of allowing 72 credits to be transferred, it was emphasized that each UW Institution would be allowed to choose which courses to accept.

There was discussion about studies that have been done illustrating the serious problem of the lack of success of students who transfer credits from tech. colleges to UW–Institutions (i.e.,: low grades or failing UW courses). There was a call for all campuses to do more research on the success or lack of success of transfer students.

Senior Vice President Marrett noted that there is still very strong pressure from legislators to have a “transparent” transfer program. Some legislatures, she noted, are talking about making changes to “Chapter 36" to facilitate this move.

It was reported that there was some confusion among some legislatures who believed that some faculty are taking advantage of the “accreditation” process to demand greater resources. It was discussed that there was a lack of understanding of the difference between “regional” and “specialized” accreditation among these legislators.

Ms. Louise Root-Robbins reported that the Sloan Foundation has been engaging in a study with a number of “demonstration” sites (UW–Madison, La Cross, Oshkosh, Parkside, and Stout) to review and make recommendations about instructional academic staff and untenured faculty workload, salary, and quality of life issues.

Highlights of BOR & Faculty Standing Committees:

The Operating Efficiency Committee discussed ideas as to how to attain the goal of cutting down the time to the degree. Some ideas such as more on-line courses and collaborative learning projects were discussed among the BOR and representative faculty.

The value of liberal arts education, as seen by the private sector was discussed by the Research and Public Service Committee. It was noted that the private sector seems to recognize the value of this while, ironically, some in the legislature, now, apparently do not.

The Partnership with the State committee addressed the continuing lack of a productive relationship with the current legislature. They noted how many legislators are viewing the UW–System as a “spoiled child.” There was a discussion as to how to improve this relationship, including establishing more links to local legislators.

Finally, during my report of UW–Superior activities, I mentioned our appreciation for Chancellor Erlenbach’s work in helping to procure the $ 5 million dollar pledge.

In the discussion, concern was expressed regarding the tech colleges offering BA degrees. Peter Nordgren pointed out that we need a meaningful dialogue; we already accept tech college courses from MN and MI.

Planning, Budgeting, and Review Council--Peter Nordgren. Noted that with M. Salzer and N. Minahan (temporary) on board, they have a full group. HPHP/Distance Learning reviews underway. Will report on SPBC draft goal statement at next Senate meeting.
1. Minutes of the 11-13-04 PBRC meeting.
Personnel Council--Randy Gabrys-Alexson. Continued review of department personnel rules. Met with chairs as group, will now meet individually. Will seek to determine fit with UW System and UW Superior guidelines. Expect report to Senate by 5/04.
Undergraduate Academic Affairs Council--Tim Cummings. Grade appeal policy will go back to departments. Proposal to eliminate concentrations/tracks will go back to departments. Will be looking at perpetual calendar.
Graduate Council--Terri Kronzer. No report.
1. Minutes of the 11-12-03 Graduate Council meeting.
Student Senate--Brad Amys. Considering two building projects: RSC and Wessman. Continued discussion of campus safety issues.
Academic Staff Senate--Mary Lee Vance. Will be updating personnel policies; review in 2/04, revision in 3/04, then to BOR. Discussed idea that teaching academic staff more than 50 percent should be granted faculty status and right to vote, except in salary/promotion/tenure decisions. (Hal: apparently, Mary Lee will e-mail a resolution to you for next Senate meeting).
OLD BUSINESS
1.

Fire alarm system. Old Business: Carol Lindberg discussed the fire alarm system on campus. Actually, there are several different systems in different buildings, some dating to 1999, some to the mid 1990s, and some from the late 1960s. Priority is to link buildings together. Working on estimate of cost of linkage. In the meantime, Lindberg stressed that everyone has a responsibility to call 911 in the event of an emergency; it is not a matter merely for building supervisor.

Nordgren/Cummings moved that the Senate encourage movement to an interconnected fire alarm system that sends messages to the 911 center. Clark/ Amys moved to amend motion that if there isn’t enough money, the first priority should be the Day Care Center and the dorms. Amendment passed. Main motion passed.

NEW BUSINESS
1. Report of the General Faculty Meeting on Retention, Tenure, and Promotion: Cummings/Toivola moved that promotion to associate professor and tenure shall be based upon the standards in place at the time of hire. There were some concerns regarding the need for departments to grow and change assignments over time. Nordgren/Cummings moved to table motion. Motion passed. Cummings/Nordgren moved to refer all remaining items to the Personnel Council and that the Personnel Council is directed to come back with a set of campus-wide recommended policies for retention, tenure, and promotion as soon as possible. Motion passed.
2. Bob Kosuth shared his letter of resignation as Director of International Education. Toivola/Cummings moved to refer the discussion of the International Education program to PBRC. Sloboda/Toivola moved to commend Bob Kosuth for his efforts in International Education. Both motions passed.
ADJOURNMENT
Faculty Senate notes taken by David Carroll. Minutes prepared and posted by Hal Bertilson, Faculty Senate Secretary, January 20, 2004.