| The Effects of Poverty on Women H. S. Bertilson, S. C. Griffith, J. Gunderson, & S. A. Cassiman Midwestern Psychological Association May 2, 2002 |
In August 2000 The Public Interest Directorate of the American
Psychological Association adopted a Resolution on Poverty and
Socioeconomic status (http://www.apa.org/pi/urban/povres.html)
urging more research, training, and public support. Much of the
focus of that resolution emphasized the plight of women,
children, and families. The effect of that call is evident in
recent publications (e.g., DeAgelis, 2001; Lott, 2002;
OConnor, 2001). The DeAgelis and O'Connor articles appeared
in recent issues of the APA Monitor. Bernice Lott's
article "Cognitive and behavioral distancing from the
poor" appeared in the American Psychologist.
Among its seventeen resolutions, APA asserted that it Will
encourage in psychological graduate and postgraduate education
and training curricula more attention to the causes and impact of
poverty, to the psychological needs of poor individuals and
families, and to the importance of developing cultural
competence and sensitivity to diversity around issues of
poverty in order to be able to help prevent and reduce the
prevalence of poverty and to treat and address the needs of
low-income clients.
While that resolution addresses graduate and postgraduate
education, it is our belief that undergraduate education should
be encouraged to include poverty in its curricula. Undergraduate
education reaches more students and is a prime opportunity for
learning values and community service.
Ten-to-fifteen years ago, several important feminist reviews of
the literature were critical of the shortage of scholarship
examining the diversity of womens lives so that many of the
complexities and distinctions of their lives were unexamined.
Theory and empirical research failed to recognize many
distinctions among women (Spelman, 1988). Russo (1990) identified
poverty as one of the major areas in need of more research for
women. The voices of poor women were particularly absent. When
poor women were included in publications, they were not included
in all their diversity. They were depicted in stereotypical,
homogeneous ways (Reid, 1993; Bing & Reid, 1996). If feminist
teaching is to represent the true diversity of womens
experiences, it must include the variety of experience of poor
women in multiple roles and contexts.
Results from several published computer searches lead the reader
to believe that few resources exist for psychologists to address
these problems. Reid (1993) reported only 86 publications. Saris
& Johnston-Robledo (2000) reported 495. Their review
indicated that nearly two-thirds of the research focused on
health-related issues. Thus underrepresentation of the experience
of women in areas outside health-related issues was substantial.
Unlike previous publications, the present program found a
substantial body of research. Beginning in 1998, we conducted
yearly searches. In addition to expanding the criteria to include
additional keywords, we found books from friends and from
internet searches of book dealer websites which were not included
in academic searches such as PsycInfo. In 1998 Griffith and
Bertilson (1998) found 479 books and chapters. As of January
2002, we have identified 772.
The sample of books we have reviewed includes a wide range of
methodologies and topics. They have included, for example, theory
about the causes of poverty (e.g., Paltiel, 1988), clinical work
in multicultural communities (e.g., Piazza & delValle, 1992),
homelessness (e.g., Jones, Levine, & Rosenberg, 1991; Shinn
& Weitzman, 1990), the lives of single parent families
(Hollyfield, 2002), and a number of other topics. Paltiel
provided theory abut the causes of female poverty and suggested
that work, family, and friendship are anchors for health. If one
or two of these anchors are missing health degradation is likely.
Piazza and delValle described a community-based family therapy
training program. They provided two vivid case histories of
working with leaders and advisors in a community empowering
community volunteers to set up family therapy services. Shinn and
Weitzman is a Journal of Social Issues issue on urban
homelessness. Jones, Levine, and Rosenberg is American
Psychologist special issue on homelessness. Hollyfield is a
book about the lives of single parent families.
For the purpose of undergraduate teaching we found first person
narratives to provide particularly meaningful teaching
opportunities. The importance of personal stories in changing
beliefs and behaviors is the theme in the developing clinical
field of narrative therapy. The narratives that are peoples
lives represent political, cultural, economic, and social
influences (Sharf, 2000). The approach of narrative therapy is to
look for themes and meanings in these stories and in the power of
words to affect the way people see themselves and others. The
purpose of narrative therapy is to help people
re-story their livesto change the narratives
about what took place (Kottler & Brown, 2000). Similarly
undergraduate students may re-story their
understandings of people who are different from them, for women
experiencing poverty. The importance of stories about personal
lives is also emphasized by Romero and Stewart (1999). They argue
that master narratives are the stories we are taught and teach us
who we are, where we've come from, what we're likely to do, and
how far we will get.
Over the past several years we moved from assigning students
readings about the effects of poverty on women (e.g., Lott,
1996), to reading first person voices of women in poverty
(Miedzian & Malinovich, 1997), to a readers'-theatre style of
sharing voices of women from resources cited in this paper, to
establishing course incentives for service learning experiences
in community agencies for women experiencing poverty. The Lott
chapter is "Global connections: The significance of women's
poverty" in Chrisler, Golden, and Rozee's Lectures in the
Psychology of Women. Among other things the Lott chapter
discusses the poverty, absence of health care, and terrible
working conditions of women in factories in less regulated
countries around the world. One of the articles we have used in
the Miedzian & Malinovich book is titled "Men always
made the big decisions." It is about abuse, not seeing her
husbands paycheck, poverty, her husband leaving her, learning to
cope, and learning to make decisions on her own. In the
readers'-theatre approach we give students different paragraphs
to read in class from the personal experiences of these women.
For a discussion of how we use interviews and first person
narratives to engage students in issues of class, see Griffith
and Bertilson (2001;
http://frontpage.uwsuper.edu/psychology/wpoverty.htm).
Interviews and voices of women experiencing poverty that we found
effective in teaching our Psychology of Women class may be found
from the following sources: (Allison, 1997; ATD Fourth World
Publications, 1995; Dujon & Withorn, 1996; Gore, 1997;
Holloway et al., 1997; Liebow, 1993; Polakow, 1993; Romero, M.
& Stewart, A. J.; Schein, 1995; Seccombe, K., 1999; Sidel,
R.). Allison's essay "A question of class" my be found
in several edited books. She speaks of growing up in a
desperately poor family, her struggle to know herself, feelings
of rejection as someone of lower SEC by the lesbian community,
and grief from physical, emotional and sexual abuse. Gore (1997)
tells of about being on welfare and the ridicule she experiences
using food stamps. Holloway et al wrote about their findings and
analysis and the voices of fourteen low-income women they visited
in their homes and workplaces over a three-year period. Elliot
Liebow was chief of the Center for the Study of Work and Mental
Health of the National Institute of Mental Health. In 1984 he
learned that he had cancer and a very limited life expectancy. He
did not want to spend his last months on the 12th floor of a
government office building. He retired as an anthropologist and
first began volunteering at a soup kitchen and subsequently at an
emergency shelter for homeless women. His book Tell the who I
am, a participant observer study of single, homeless women in
emergency shelters, was published in 1993. Liebow describes the
conditions of the lives of these women, the hassles, the
hardships, and their survival needs and includes their voices.
Elliot Liebow died in September 1994. Romero and Stewart framed
their work as capturing "master narratives" of women's
lives. It includes 16 chapters. We have used "From Black
middle class to homeless and (almost) back" in our
readers'-theatre classroom approach. In this approach brief
sections of a narrative are distributed to students. They are
asked to read these snippets out loud and then write reaction
papers to hearing these stories. Virginia Schein's (1995) book Working
from the margins: Voices of mothers in poverty is based on
interviews with 30 women. The eleven chapters are organized
around the themes that emerged from these interviews. Karen
Seccombe (1999) "So you think I drive a Cadillac?"
is the stories and perspectives 47 women who are welfare
recipients.
| References |
Allison, D. (1997). A question of class. In R. Bresdin (Ed.).
Perspectives: Women Studies. Boulder Colorado: Courseware
Publishing, 58-72.
ATD Fourth World Publications. (1995). This is how we live:
Listening to the poorest families.
Bing, V. M., & Reid, P. T. (1996). Unkown women and unknowing
research: Consequences of color and class in feminist psychology.
In N. Goldberger, J., J. Tarule, B. Clinchy, & M. Belenky
(Eds.). Knowledge, difference, and power. New York: Basic Books.
DeAngelis, T. (October 2001). Those who remain on welfare often
have disabilities. Monitor on Psychology, 32-9, 76.
Dujon, D., & Withorn, A. 1996). For crying out loud:
Womens poverty in the United States. Boston: South End
Press.
Gore, A. (1997). Mother courage. In V. Cyrus (Ed.). Experiencing
race, class, and gender in the United States. Mountain View,
California: Mayfield Publishing, 144-146.
Griffith, S. C., & Bertilson, H. S. (1998). Where is the
voice of women in poverty in the psychology classroom? In K. A.
Rhoades & A. Statham (Eds.). Speaking Out: Women, Poverty,
and Public Policy: Proceedings of the Twenty-Third Annual Women's
Studies Conference, University of Wisconsin Womens Studies
Consortium, 183-190.
Griffith, S. C., & Bertilson, H. S. (2001). Inclusion of
class and poverty in womens studies. Twenty-Sixth Annual
Womens Studies Conference, University of Wisconsin
Womens studies Consortium, UW-Waukesha,
http://frontpage.uwsuper.edu/psychology/wpoverty.htm.
Holloway, S. D., Fuller, B., Rambaud, M. F., &
Eggers-Pierola, C. (1997). Through my own eyes: Single mothers
and the cultures of poverty. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Hollyfield, L. (2002). Moving up and out: Poverty, education, and
the single parent family. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
Jones, J. M., Levine, I. S., & Rosenberg, A. A. (1991).
[Special Issue]: Homelessness. American Psychologist, 46,
1108-1252.
Kottler, J. A., & Brown, R. W. (2000). Introduction to
therapeutic counseling: Voices from the field. Brooks/Cole.
Fourth Edition.
Liebow, E. (1993). Tell them who I am: The lives of homeless
women. New York: Penguin Books. (Paper).
Lott, B. (1996). Global connections: The significance of
women's poverty. In J. C. Chrisler, C. Golden, & P. D. Rozee
(Eds.). Lectures on the Psychology of Women. New York:
McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc.
Lott, B. (2002). Cognitive and behavioral distancing from the
poor. American Psychologist, 57, 100-110.
Miedzian, M., & Malinovich, A. (1997). Generations: A
century of women speak about their lives. New York: The
Atlantic Monthly Press.
OConnor, E. M. (October 2001). Psychology responds to
poverty. Monitor on Psychology, 32-9, 81.
Paltiel, F. L. (1988). Is being poor a mental health hazard?
Women and Health, 12, 189-211.
Piazza, J., & deValle, C. M. (1992). Community-based family
therapy training. An example of work with poor and minority
families. Journal of Strategic and Systemic Therapies, 11, 53-69.
Polakow, V. (1993). Lives on the edge: Single mothers and their
children in the other America. Chicago: The University of Chicago
Press.
Reid, P. T. (1993). Poor women in psychological research: Shut up
and shut out. Psychology of Women Quarterly, 17, 133-150.
Romero, M., & Stewart, A. J. (1999). Womens untold
stories: Breaking silence, talking back, voicing complexity. New
York: Routledge.
Russo, N. F. (1990). Overview: Forging research priorities for
womens mental health. American Psychologist, 45, 366-373.
Saris, R. N, & Johnston-Robledo, I. (September 2000). Poor
women are still shut out of mainstream psychology. Psychology of
Women Quarterly, 24, 233-235.
Schein, B. E. (1995). Working from the Margins: Voices of mothers
of poverty. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
Seccombe, K. (1999). So you think I drive a Cadillac?
Boston: Allyn and Bacon.
Sharf, R. S. (2000). Theories of psychotherapy & Counseling:
Concepts and cases. Brooks/Cole. Second Edition.
Shinn, M., & Weitzman, B. C. (1990). (Eds.). Urban
homelessness. [Special issue]. Journal of Social Issues, 46,
1-219.
Sidel, R. (1998). Keeping women and children last: Americas
war on the poor. New York: Penguin Books.
Spelman, E. V. (1988). Inessential woman: Problems of exclusion
in feminist thought. Boston, MA: Beacon Press.